I Alienated Everyone By Day One": Why Cultural Humility Is A Prerequisite for Effective Leadership

Bonus Insight #6 from podcast conversations with leaders who leave the world better than they found it

Rob Alhadeff tells a story about his first day leading a school project in Uganda that every leader should hear:

"We had our first team meeting under a tree. It started raining. I was sat there in the rain getting more and more annoyed. The moment it stopped raining, everyone turned up. And I was absolutely furious. I launched into it without taking into account any of the cultural complexities or the fact that I was a guest/outsider in the community."

He alienated everyone instantly. For two weeks, the team was standoffish. He had to rebuild trust by playing football with the local team and scoring a critical goal against a neighboring village.

"That mistake on day one—I intend to never repeat that mistake for the rest of my life. That's how intense I feel about it."

What went wrong? Rob brought London-mindset leadership to Ugandan-context reality. He had technical competence but zero cultural humility.

And that combination doesn't just fail. It damages.

The Problem With Expertise Without Context

Rob was genuinely trying to help. He'd come to Uganda specifically to work with schools. He had finance expertise. He had good intentions.

But on that first day, he made a critical error: he assumed his expertise meant he could lead immediately.

He sat in the rain, expecting the team to show up in the rain, because that's what professional teams in London do. When they didn't, he interpreted it as lack of commitment.

The team had completely rational reasons for not sitting in the rain for a meeting. But Rob didn't know those reasons because he hadn't taken time to understand local context.

His expertise wasn't wrong. His application was wrong. Because he didn't understand the context well enough to lead effectively.

This happens constantly when leaders move into new contexts—new communities, new countries, new organizations, even new departments.

They bring expertise. They see problems. They jump straight to leading.

And they alienate everyone by failing to recognize that their expertise only matters if they understand context well enough to apply it appropriately.

What Cultural Humility Actually Requires

Cultural humility isn't just being polite. It's recognizing that every context has logic, and you don't understand that logic yet.

People aren't showing up to meetings in the rain? There's a reason. You might think it's bad reason, but understanding it is prerequisite to leading.

Programs aren't being implemented the way you planned? There's a reason. Maybe your plan didn't account for realities you couldn't see.

Stakeholders aren't responding the way you expect? There's a reason. Maybe your expectations came from different cultural context.

Cultural humility means starting with assumption: "I don't understand the full picture yet. I need to learn before I can lead."

Rob learned this the hard way: "Every time I deal with a different colleague or I go to a different school or I'm in a different area or country, you have to change how you operate every single time."

Not just adjust. Fundamentally change. Because the logic of effective operation is different in each context.

The 30-Day Listening Period

Here's what Rob should have done (and what every leader entering new context should do):

Spend the first 30 days only listening and asking questions.

Not "listening while planning how you'll fix things." Actually listening to understand local logic.

Ask questions like:

• How do teams typically meet here?

• What does professional behavior look like in this context?

• When people don't do X, what's usually the reason?

• What am I missing about how things work here?

Don't lead until you understand enough to lead appropriately.

This feels wasteful to many leaders. "I'm here to help. I have expertise. Why spend a month just listening?"

Because leadership without context isn't leadership. It's imposition.

And imposition destroys the trust you need to actually help.

When "Helping" Becomes Harm

Rob's story reveals something important: good intentions with bad cultural understanding create harm, not help.

He genuinely wanted to help the schools. He had real expertise to offer. But by leading without cultural humility, he:

• Alienated the team he needed to work with

• Damaged trust that took weeks to rebuild

• Modeled disrespect (even though he didn't intend to)

• Made his own work harder by creating resistance

This is the paradox of helping without humility: your expertise becomes liability because you apply it inappropriately.

Organizations do this constantly in international development, community work, even internal change management:

"We know best practice. We're bringing proven models. Why aren't people implementing them?"

Because best practice from one context doesn't automatically translate to another context. And pushing it without understanding local reality creates resistance, not transformation.

What Recovery Looks Like

Rob couldn't undo his day one mistake. But he could recover:

He apologized. "I apologized one-on-one to each person. There were six of us in that meeting. I apologized in a different way to each person."

Not a general "sorry if anyone was offended." Specific acknowledgment to each person of how he'd been wrong.

He built relationships outside work. Playing football with the local team gave him access to the community in ways professional meetings couldn't.

He learned to read context before acting. Now he explicitly asks: "What do I need to understand about operating in this context before I make decisions?"

But recovery took weeks. And it only worked because Rob was genuinely humble about his mistake.

Many leaders don't recover because they can't admit they were wrong. They just keep pushing their expertise harder, creating more damage.

The Cultural Humility Checklist

Before leading in any new context, ask yourself:

"Do I understand local logic well enough to lead appropriately?"

If no, don't lead yet. Listen first.

"What am I assuming based on my previous contexts that might not apply here?"

Every leader brings assumptions. Name them. Test them before acting on them.

"Who can teach me how things work here?"

Find cultural guides. People who can explain local logic. Trust them over your expertise.

"What mistakes am I likely to make as outsider?"

Ask this directly. People will tell you if you ask genuinely.

"How will I know if I'm getting this wrong?"

Set up feedback loops. Create space for people to tell you when you're missing cultural context.

Why This Matters Beyond International Work

Rob's story is about Uganda, but the principle applies everywhere:

Any time you're leading outside your cultural context, you need humility more than expertise.

Moving from corporate to nonprofit? Different cultural logic.

Moving from one department to another? Different norms and assumptions.

Leading team from different demographic backgrounds than yours? Different cultural expectations.

Working with community you're not from? Different values and priorities.

In all these contexts, your expertise only matters if you understand context well enough to apply it appropriately.

And you can't understand context without spending significant time listening before leading.

From Expert To Learner

Rob's day-one mistake taught him something crucial: effective leadership starts with learner posture, not expert posture.

"That was a huge learning for me. When we're thinking about new areas, I highlight this mistake to colleagues as well."

He's not ashamed of the mistake anymore. He's integrated the learning. And he uses it to teach others.

That's cultural humility: recognizing you will make mistakes, learning from them, and adjusting how you operate.

Next time you're entering new context—new community, new organization, new country, new role—resist the urge to lead immediately.

Spend 30 days listening. Ask questions. Learn local logic. Build relationships.

Only then will your expertise actually be useful.

Because cultural humility isn't obstacle to effective leadership. It's prerequisite.

And the cost of leading without it? You might alienate everyone by day one.

Just ask Rob.

This is bonus insight #6 in an extended series exploring lessons from podcast conversations with leaders who leave the world better than they found it.

Subscribe for insights on leading with cultural humility.